The World's Best Restaurants · 2026
Chicago, United States
Smyth builds a highly personal Midwestern cuisine from close attention to farms, wild plants, preserved ingredients and the changing character of a product over time.
Plan your table
Smyth builds a highly personal Midwestern cuisine from close attention to farms, wild plants, preserved ingredients and the changing character of a product over time. John B. Shields composes in layers: grain may become shell, sauce and seasoning; fruit or root can move between savoury and sweet; fermentation creates depth without fixing the menu to a single tradition. Karen Urie Shields gives pastry equal authorship rather than treating dessert as a separate coda. The most recent work is more coherent than earlier iterations, and the dining room now supports its complexity with greater assurance. The result is demanding, distinctive cooking with a genuine sense of place.
Farm products, wild herbs, grains and preservation are developed into an identifiable cuisine rather than arranged as a seasonal inventory.
John and Karen Shields work across the full progression, allowing pastry, fermentation and savoury technique to answer one another instead of dividing the meal into separate departments.
Dishes change continually, but recurring products and techniques are revisited with greater precision, so experimentation builds a record rather than replacing it.
The editorial review verifies the current team, two live menu formats, prices, hours and producer-led direction. It weighs recent professional evidence of stronger coherence and service against current criticism of value, individual later courses and tableware friction; those reservations cap Plate at 38 and Experience at 18. No direct visit is claimed, and isolated diner reports are not treated as proof of a systematic failure.
Plan your table